Menu
Home
Post Something
Forums
Current Activity
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
News & Features
The Marketplace
Cars for Sale
Engine and Performance
Chassis and Wheels
Exterior and Body
Interior and Cockpit
ICE - In Car Entertainment
Car Shops and Services
Toys and Wares
All Other Stuff
Jobs and Vacancies
Looking For
Members
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Current Activity
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Reply to thread
See what others are reading now! Try Forums >
Current Activity
Home
Forums
Main Forums
Interests
Motorsport Specifics
Formula 1
Why a chicane could not be built.
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Message
<blockquote data-quote="XXX" data-source="post: 656393" data-attributes="member: 551"><p>Another good read "Why the chicane could not be built"</p><p></p><p>The chicane could never be built. And I am certain Michelin knew it.</p><p></p><p>If the chicane had been built, the FIA would be in an untenable legal position under US law. One mistake, one brake lockup, one tire deflation and it would be an accident for sure. Alternatively, no one knows how the chicane would effect the Bridgestone runners. One of them hits the wall on the way out of the chicane and all they need claim is that running slowly through that turn made the tire pressures lower because the tires were colder causing sideawall failure, and you have a court case.</p><p></p><p>The lawyer for the prosecution would only need to ask one question:</p><p></p><p>"Mr. Whiting, as Safety Delegate for the FIA, you are aware of the rules governing design, engineering, simulation, safety testing, and homologation of circuit changes. Were any of those rules followed in building this chicane?"</p><p></p><p>[Charlie Whiting] "umm... no"</p><p></p><p>Judgement for the plaintiff. Next case, Your Honor.</p><p></p><p>So the FIA could not allow the chicane. But could they run as a non-championship event? To protect themselves, legally, the FIA would be forced to withdraw their sanction of the event, at which point the IMS' insurance stops. They are insured for sanctioned events only. No sanction, no insurance.</p><p></p><p>IMS could not allow the event to go forward without it. The 120,000+ spectators in the stands and the infield, the track workers, safety officials, indeeed, even pit workers and paddock hangers-on such as Jenson Button's dad and Jean Todt's girlfriend were all risks for the track. One good accident and the track is lost, along with America's premier motorsport event, the Indy 500. So that option is out.</p><p></p><p>And how did Michelin know? They have a small army of liability lawyers on staff. Every accident that may involve a Michelin tire failure brings them swarming to prove "it's not our fault". Do you really believe the only communication between the track and Spartansburg, SC, was technical? The legal eagles were in on it, I am sure, or Michelin would be incredibly incompetent, more so than now. And I would bet the PR folks were involved, as well.</p><p></p><p>So call it the Great Michelin Misdirection. They came up with a bunch of ideas which they knew could never be accepted, then plead that they tried. They never mentioned that their ideas were legally untenable.</p><p></p><p>Sadly, many people have been fooled by this, including, it seems, Nigel Mansell and many forumites.</p><p></p><p>Also go here, its an interview with a lawyer.</p><p></p><p><a href="http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/news/lawinaction/ram/lawinaction_current.ram" target="_blank">http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/news/lawinaction/ram/lawinaction_current.ram</a></p><p></p><p>Youll need real player and slide the indicator to about the 22nd minute and 20 seconds. </p><p></p><p><span style="color: red">FYI this is not my article its a copy and paste job for your readin pleasure.</span></p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="XXX, post: 656393, member: 551"] Another good read "Why the chicane could not be built" The chicane could never be built. And I am certain Michelin knew it. If the chicane had been built, the FIA would be in an untenable legal position under US law. One mistake, one brake lockup, one tire deflation and it would be an accident for sure. Alternatively, no one knows how the chicane would effect the Bridgestone runners. One of them hits the wall on the way out of the chicane and all they need claim is that running slowly through that turn made the tire pressures lower because the tires were colder causing sideawall failure, and you have a court case. The lawyer for the prosecution would only need to ask one question: "Mr. Whiting, as Safety Delegate for the FIA, you are aware of the rules governing design, engineering, simulation, safety testing, and homologation of circuit changes. Were any of those rules followed in building this chicane?" [Charlie Whiting] "umm... no" Judgement for the plaintiff. Next case, Your Honor. So the FIA could not allow the chicane. But could they run as a non-championship event? To protect themselves, legally, the FIA would be forced to withdraw their sanction of the event, at which point the IMS' insurance stops. They are insured for sanctioned events only. No sanction, no insurance. IMS could not allow the event to go forward without it. The 120,000+ spectators in the stands and the infield, the track workers, safety officials, indeeed, even pit workers and paddock hangers-on such as Jenson Button's dad and Jean Todt's girlfriend were all risks for the track. One good accident and the track is lost, along with America's premier motorsport event, the Indy 500. So that option is out. And how did Michelin know? They have a small army of liability lawyers on staff. Every accident that may involve a Michelin tire failure brings them swarming to prove "it's not our fault". Do you really believe the only communication between the track and Spartansburg, SC, was technical? The legal eagles were in on it, I am sure, or Michelin would be incredibly incompetent, more so than now. And I would bet the PR folks were involved, as well. So call it the Great Michelin Misdirection. They came up with a bunch of ideas which they knew could never be accepted, then plead that they tried. They never mentioned that their ideas were legally untenable. Sadly, many people have been fooled by this, including, it seems, Nigel Mansell and many forumites. Also go here, its an interview with a lawyer. [url="http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/news/lawinaction/ram/lawinaction_current.ram"]http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/news/lawinaction/ram/lawinaction_current.ram[/url] Youll need real player and slide the indicator to about the 22nd minute and 20 seconds. [color=red]FYI this is not my article its a copy and paste job for your readin pleasure.[/color] [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Post reply
The Marketplace Latest
Mugen MS-C Full Bucket Seat Civic Type R FL5 FK8
Started by
aycy
Engine and Performance
Boost Logic Boostlogic Oil Cooler Kit R35 GTR GTR35
Started by
aycy
Engine and Performance
Linney IHI 800WHP Turbo Kit R35 GTR35 GTR
Started by
aycy
Engine and Performance
Varis R35 GTR GTR35 Front Bumper
Started by
aycy
Exterior and Body
HKS Spec R Titanium Exhaust with Y pipe R35 GTR GTR35
Started by
aycy
Engine and Performance
2016 BMW 120i LCI M Sport F20 1.6 Auto
Started by
aycy
Cars for sale
GR Yaris H&R Front Rear Anti Roll Bar
Started by
aycy
Chassis and Wheels
BBS RI-A 10J God Spec FK8 FL5 Honda Civic Type R...
Started by
aycy
Chassis and Wheels
Rays Gram Lights 57CR GR Yaris Subaru Impreza Rim...
Started by
aycy
Chassis and Wheels
2019 Toyota FORTUNER 2.4 VRZ 4X4 (A) Diesel
Started by
aycy
Cars for sale
Posts refresh every 5 minutes
is it worth to mod rb20
is it any worth to mod rb20?
n what options do those who running it..
Reasons why you like ur MR
:_:
Just to know what everyone feels about their ride.
AW11, SW20, ZZW30 everyone welcome
Just need to state version of your MR and reasons why you like it so much.
Metal Gasket Thickness
want to fit in a Metal Gasket Thickness for my 63t
what material is available and what should i use
i am not going to boost that high in the future maybe 1.2bar
what are the side effects of too thick gasket
so far...
Recent Posts
Looking for 2.5-16 cosworth halfcut for 190E
Started by
Tuanku.J
Euro
Thrills and Spills at Zhuhai: Porsche Carrera Cup Asia Rounds 3 & 4 Recap
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Proton Records High Demand for S70 with 1 Unit Booked every 4 minutes
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Toyota Malaysia Enters Regional GT Racing with TGR Racing Malaysia
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Home Win and Double Podium for Akash Nandy at Sepang Season Opener
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Search
Online now
Enjoying Zerotohundred?
Log-in
for an ad-less experience
Home
Forums
Main Forums
Interests
Motorsport Specifics
Formula 1
Why a chicane could not be built.