Menu
Home
Post Something
Forums
Current Activity
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
News & Features
The Marketplace
Cars for Sale
Engine and Performance
Chassis and Wheels
Exterior and Body
Interior and Cockpit
ICE - In Car Entertainment
Car Shops and Services
Toys and Wares
All Other Stuff
Jobs and Vacancies
Looking For
Members
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Current Activity
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Reply to thread
See what others are reading now! Try Forums >
Current Activity
Home
Forums
Main Forums
Interests
Do-It-Yourself Garage
Oil Filter Magnet
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Message
<blockquote data-quote="coldfish" data-source="post: 315234" data-attributes="member: 2115"><p>i just did an oil change. i had hdd magnets on the side and the bottom of the filter. here's the thing. i had the foreman saw it off with a cutting wheel. the cutting wheel is extremely fast, much better than handsaw. u will find lots of metal saw dust residue from hand sawing or band sawing but very very little from a very fast cutting wheel. in fact, when u use a cutting wheel, most of the saw dusts just burns off in sparks. my mistake was, we took off the magnets to put on the new filter before we saw the old filter. that way, whatever debris left in the filter may just float around in oil residue. anyway, it cut like an engine burning oil. white smoke all over as expected.</p><p></p><p>we in an upright manner, with the inlet and outlet holes pointing up. not sawing all the way down so we can have a sample of the oil inside. didn't saw right in the middle. upon sawing down to 3/4 way, we pry the filter apart. we compared the residue oil at the bottom filter and whatever came out from my oilsump. the filter's oil residue was much thicker (very viscous, almost sludgy) and darker in comparison to the oil from my oil sump (fully synthetic @ 7000km). then again, the oil from the oilsump was still very thin and fine. i just wanna change cos i've been travelling to kuantan and also left the car around for 3 weeks of not driving.</p><p></p><p>so. guess where are all the debris?</p><p></p><p>in the paper layer of the filter. that's where you'll see the chunky ones. not that they are huge. they're grainy and trapped in the paper. i WOULD LIKE TO THINK that the thicker oil was so because the finer grains of debris from engine wear did not get filtered in the paper but still got trapped because of the magnets. which also makes sense because if the filter alone doesn't trap most of the debris in the paper layer, what's the point of even having it? </p><p></p><p>the magnet helped to trap the finer debris that the paper layer couldn't catch. so if we were to think we can see huge chuck of metals inside the filter walls after using the magnets, that's hallucination. i feel that it's wishful thinking. heck, i'm still using the darn magnets =)</p><p></p><p>hope the finding helps. sorry i didn't bring my camera. it was too early in the morning to realize i wanted to saw off the filter and see what's in it. </p><p></p><p>by the way, the filter was an original honda filter. engine oil was due in 10000km but i always change earlier.</p><p></p><p>if you can suggest a better way to dismantle the filter other than using a highspeed cutting wheel, tell me how. i'd do it again in my next oil change. and with my camera around.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="coldfish, post: 315234, member: 2115"] i just did an oil change. i had hdd magnets on the side and the bottom of the filter. here's the thing. i had the foreman saw it off with a cutting wheel. the cutting wheel is extremely fast, much better than handsaw. u will find lots of metal saw dust residue from hand sawing or band sawing but very very little from a very fast cutting wheel. in fact, when u use a cutting wheel, most of the saw dusts just burns off in sparks. my mistake was, we took off the magnets to put on the new filter before we saw the old filter. that way, whatever debris left in the filter may just float around in oil residue. anyway, it cut like an engine burning oil. white smoke all over as expected. we in an upright manner, with the inlet and outlet holes pointing up. not sawing all the way down so we can have a sample of the oil inside. didn't saw right in the middle. upon sawing down to 3/4 way, we pry the filter apart. we compared the residue oil at the bottom filter and whatever came out from my oilsump. the filter's oil residue was much thicker (very viscous, almost sludgy) and darker in comparison to the oil from my oil sump (fully synthetic @ 7000km). then again, the oil from the oilsump was still very thin and fine. i just wanna change cos i've been travelling to kuantan and also left the car around for 3 weeks of not driving. so. guess where are all the debris? in the paper layer of the filter. that's where you'll see the chunky ones. not that they are huge. they're grainy and trapped in the paper. i WOULD LIKE TO THINK that the thicker oil was so because the finer grains of debris from engine wear did not get filtered in the paper but still got trapped because of the magnets. which also makes sense because if the filter alone doesn't trap most of the debris in the paper layer, what's the point of even having it? the magnet helped to trap the finer debris that the paper layer couldn't catch. so if we were to think we can see huge chuck of metals inside the filter walls after using the magnets, that's hallucination. i feel that it's wishful thinking. heck, i'm still using the darn magnets =) hope the finding helps. sorry i didn't bring my camera. it was too early in the morning to realize i wanted to saw off the filter and see what's in it. by the way, the filter was an original honda filter. engine oil was due in 10000km but i always change earlier. if you can suggest a better way to dismantle the filter other than using a highspeed cutting wheel, tell me how. i'd do it again in my next oil change. and with my camera around. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Post reply
The Marketplace Latest
Evasive EVS Tuning Carbon Body Kit Honda Civic Type...
Started by
aycy
Exterior and Body
Mugen MS-C Full Bucket Seat Civic Type R FL5 FK8
Started by
aycy
Engine and Performance
Boost Logic Boostlogic Oil Cooler Kit R35 GTR GTR35
Started by
aycy
Engine and Performance
Linney IHI 800WHP Turbo Kit R35 GTR35 GTR
Started by
aycy
Engine and Performance
Varis R35 GTR GTR35 Front Bumper
Started by
aycy
Exterior and Body
HKS Spec R Titanium Exhaust with Y pipe R35 GTR GTR35
Started by
aycy
Engine and Performance
2016 BMW 120i LCI M Sport F20 1.6 Auto
Started by
aycy
Cars for sale
GR Yaris H&R Front Rear Anti Roll Bar
Started by
aycy
Chassis and Wheels
BBS RI-A 10J God Spec FK8 FL5 Honda Civic Type R...
Started by
aycy
Chassis and Wheels
Rays Gram Lights 57CR GR Yaris Subaru Impreza Rim...
Started by
aycy
Chassis and Wheels
Posts refresh every 5 minutes
the case of idling gone bad again
hi guys...was wondering if u guys cld kindly offer me ur opinions or advices/solutions on wat cld b d problem im facing wiz my car rite now
cut long story short its regards to my car's idling..its x like d usual up...
- Fibreglass -
Eh where to get the fibreglass cloth/mat in Klang Valley ?
Any info would be great
Thanks in advance
newbie....
As it seems, there has been a need for another technical discussion on tuning theory. I think more and more questions arise why you run 12:1 afr vs. 13:1 or 14:1 or this certain ignition timing. Anyone can just find...
Recent Posts
Looking for 2.5-16 cosworth halfcut for 190E
Started by
Tuanku.J
Euro
Thrills and Spills at Zhuhai: Porsche Carrera Cup Asia Rounds 3 & 4 Recap
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Proton Records High Demand for S70 with 1 Unit Booked every 4 minutes
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Toyota Malaysia Enters Regional GT Racing with TGR Racing Malaysia
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Home Win and Double Podium for Akash Nandy at Sepang Season Opener
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Search
Online now
Enjoying Zerotohundred?
Log-in
for an ad-less experience
Home
Forums
Main Forums
Interests
Do-It-Yourself Garage
Oil Filter Magnet